Forex System Auto Trading

Alwayslearning February 24th, 2010 at 8:49 am

Looking at the system only, rather than the psychological aspects of trading, I can’t say I am impressed. The instructions on how to build a swing chart do not match the diagrams and are therefore confusing. The expanation on what to do if it is NOT a 50% retracement are very unclear to say the least. The book could have done with a thorough edit before publication. Much of the material is available on the authors website but the explanations are no clearer.

The author talks about how he is not a fan of technical indicators (one of the reasons I bought this book) and then goes on to talk about wave theory as a type of technical indicator! Patterns (for me) are way too subjective to use in trading and this is really all about pattern recognition.

Where are the examples of trading that failed (way more instructive than pattern success)? Where are the ‘difficult’ patterns to call and the mistakes made?

The author recommends using high leverage with ‘beer accounts’ like $500 which is a sure fire way to blow the account. He recommends that you use 10:1 leverage with this size of account and 5:1 leverage with $10000 account. These levels willl blow the account sooner or later particularly with his stop loss ‘strategy’ of tight stops based around risk ratio.

The trader psychology part is fine but can be found in many other trader books but I give it two stars because of this.

Rating: 2 / 5

David Roberts February 24th, 2010 at 9:19 am

1) I do not think this is a good “Getting Started” book. I’d recommend the Dummies series as a first book. It’s simple, to the point and much more organized. If this is the book you start with, you will end up more confused.

2) I honestly can say I do not think I picked up one piece of useful information from this. Granted this isn’t the first book I read so maybe there’s a point in there somewhere that someone might get… but not me.

3) Bad writing. I can see where there was potential in some things he wrote to be useful, but it just didn’t come across that way. No offense meant to Archer. He is, after all an active TRADER (at least according to the back cover) and not a writer, but the writing makes it difficult to get through.

I only read this because my mom got it for me. I wouldn’t have bought this book myself.
Rating: 1 / 5

Mark Twain February 24th, 2010 at 12:10 pm

I found this book to be the missing link in my trading. I’ve long been struggling to find a framework with which I could understand and develop a complete trading strategy. The author does an excellent job with the codex approach in both explaining his framework and providing an example using his Goodman Swing trading system (in addition he also shares this system for those would like to use it). The book also provides very good insight into all the components of a complete trading strategy, how they work together and why they must be complimentary, thus allowing the strategy to evolve or adapt. The author was very prompt in responding to my email asking for some clarifications, and in fact provided me with more information than I asked for. The book is well written and edited, there was very little that was not clearly explained and very understandable. Thanks again to Mr. Archer and his editors for what I believe is one of the best books on trading system/strategy development available today.
Rating: 5 / 5